How I Screen Tenants Using Credit Reports – A Markham Real Estate Leasing Guide

How I Screen Tenants Using Credit Reports – A Markham Real Estate Leasing Guide

Recently, I met a Markham homeowner who leased their property to a so-called “professional tenant”—someone who knows exactly how to manipulate the legal system. Despite the landlord being tough and aggressive in handling the situation, they now find themselves entangled in what could become a long and costly legal battle.

This tenant isn’t just an ordinary family down on their luck. They’ve already defaulted on several rental payments and continue to position themselves as the victim, resisting eviction with alarming confidence. Unfortunately, this scenario isn’t unique—and it highlights a critical truth in real estate leasing: screening for the right tenant isn’t optional, it’s essential.

A bad rental decision can turn a promising investment property into a financial and legal nightmare for months—sometimes years. That’s why, in my leasing process, I focus on one powerful screening tool: the credit report.

Why Landlords Must Learn to Read Credit Reports

I often hear landlords say they’ve spent three to four months reviewing dozens of rental applications, leaving their properties vacant for far too long. This kind of delay doesn’t just hurt your cash flow—it adds unnecessary stress.

In my experience, once you know how to properly read a credit report, you usually only need to review around 10 applications to identify a solid tenant. Even in today’s competitive rental market—where tenants have more options than ever—every application deserves a closer look.

It’s not about rushing to fill a vacancy. It’s about finding someone who will respect your property and pay reliably.

Take, for example, a credit score of 670. At first glance, it might seem too low—but the number alone doesn’t tell the full story. If the lower score is due to a minor oversight or a one-time dispute, that tenant might still be financially responsible. Learning how to read a full credit report gives you the clarity and confidence to make informed leasing decisions.

Understanding the Structure of a Credit Report

Credit reports can seem overwhelming at first, but they’re usually organized into 10 key sections:

  1. Report Summary & Reference Info
    Shows the report date, reference number, and the input details used to generate the report.

  2. Overview Summary
    Lists total accounts, total balance, and monthly repayment obligations—a quick snapshot of the applicant’s financial health.

  3. Credit Score (e.g., Beacon Score)
    Includes the actual credit score and alerts if any suspicious activity or mismatched information is detected.

  4. Personal Information
    Name, SIN, DOB, address history, contact info. Always cross-check with the rental application.

  5. Employment Info
    Lists current and previous employers. This section isn’t always 100% accurate and may require explanation.

  6. Inquiry History
    Shows which institutions have pulled the report and when. Frequent recent inquiries may indicate financial stress.

  7. Public Records
    Includes bankruptcies, court judgments, and collections—major red flags.

  8. Financing Statements (Secured Loans)
    Often overlooked. Covers loans secured against personal assets like vehicles, solar panels, or liens for unpaid renovations.

  9. Trade Lines (Account History)
    The core of the report. Includes each account’s type, limit, balance, repayment status, and payment history.

  10. Negative Banking Records
    Displays NSF (Non-Sufficient Funds) history and overdraft issues. Not common—but critical when present.

What I Look for When Screening Tenants

Here’s how I use credit reports to screen tenants effectively:

✅ 1. Go Beyond the Score

  • A score of 670 isn’t automatically bad. Understand why it’s low.

  • Is it one unresolved issue? Or a pattern of missed payments?

✅ 2. Cross-Check Personal Details

  • Verify that the applicant’s name, address, and employer match the rental application.

  • Inconsistencies could signal a red flag—or even identity concerns.

✅ 3. Analyze Credit Utilization

  • High utilization (e.g., using 90% of available credit) suggests financial pressure.

  • A healthy usage rate is typically under 30%. Many reliable tenants fall below 20%.

✅ 4. Watch for Signs of Fraud

  • Look for alerts or a "DN" (Deceased Notice) status.
    These can indicate fraud, such as using another person's identity or triggering internal security flags in the credit bureau system.

✅ 5. Identify Serious Delinquency

  • Public Records: bankruptcies, court judgments, collections.

  • Trade Lines with R9 or I9: the worst possible ratings for revolving or installment accounts.

  • NSF Records: repeated bounced cheques are major warning signs.

✅ Quick Reference:

  • R9 = Worst rating for credit cards or lines of credit (e.g., unpaid, sent to collections)

  • I9 = Worst rating for loans (e.g., unpaid car loan or furniture financing)

  • NSF = Bank records showing non-sufficient funds or bounced payments

Bonus Tip: Confirm with a Live Credit Report

With the rise of digitally altered or fake credit reports, I often ask applicants to:

  • Authorize a credit pull through Equifax or TransUnion, or

  • Show the live version of their report on their phone in person

You can also request supporting docs like their T4 slip or pay stubs to verify income consistency.

Final Thoughts

When landlords learn how to properly read a credit report—not just the score—they gain:

  • ✅ Faster access to quality tenants

  • ✅ Fewer rental gaps and vacant months

  • ✅ Peace of mind with reduced legal risk

For tenants, the takeaway is clear: keep your credit clean and consistent, because your profile speaks before you do.

In the end, a single report could protect your investment—or cost you months of legal battles. I choose to read closely. And I recommend you do too.




WhatsApp Chat